[ncdnhc-discuss] Election results! NOT TRUSTED

[Dany Vandromme]

Milton Mueller wrote:
> 
> Here are the results of the NCDNH Constituency vote.
> A complete, statistical report will be sent to the
> constituency by the election operator (Elisabeth
> Porteneuve) tomorrow (Feb. 27).
> 
> 1. All resolutions were ratified by substantial margins
> 
> 2. New Adcom:
>    Eung Hwi CHUN, AP
>    Dany Vandromme, EU
>    Harold Feld, NA
>    Thierry Amoussoubgo, AF
>    Erick Iriarte, LAC
> 
> 3. New Names Council members:
>    Eung Hwi CHUN, AP - 18 votes
>    Harold Feld, NA  - 10 votes
> 
>    Tie:
>    Erick Iriarte, LAC - 5 votes
>    (note: includes INIA vote)
>    Dany Vandromme, EU - 5 votes
> 
> 4. We have two options:
>    a. One of the two tied candidates can withdraw, if
>       they wish to concede to the other. Of course,
>       both candidates have every right to remain if
>       they choose.
>    b. We can hold a runoff election between these two
>       candidates.
> 
>    So, Dany, Erick, please indicate your intention
> and if necessary we will proceed with a direct runoff
> between Dany Vandromme and Erick Iriarte. We need to
> hear from you by Friday.
> 
-
Milton and others:

This election has been a complet failure.
It is the first time in my life I see a vote, with the voting list not
closed before the start of the vote, the closing date not respected, and
the voting officers including votes not supported by a ballot. The vote
results should have been posted as planned on Feb 23th. They were not,
because the voting rules were not fully understood by the voting
officers, nor by voters.
Membership list were supposed closed from Friday 8th. From that, the
draft voting list was produced on thursday, but none of the voting
officer did check and close it prior the vote start.

A tie vote, which is not part of the established voting rules, with an
undefined voting list would not produce the same result for the last NC
rep, since emanating from a different distribution of voters, with
different rationale for voting.

The vote are so clear to everyone that we see now members, voting for
the tie, before that the vote has been organized and opened:
======================================================================================
Subject: [ncdnhc-adcom] Re: [ncdnhc-discuss] Re: [Fwd: Fwd: Ballot Not received]
Date:    Mon, 25 Feb 2002 10:30:26 -0500
From:    Pablo Allietti <pabloa at inia.org.uy>
Organization:  INIA La Estanzuela
To:      YJ Park <yjpark at myepark.com>
CC:      Elisabeth Porteneuve <Elisabeth.Porteneuve at cetp.ipsl.fr>,
         vany_martinez at yahoo.com, vany at sdnp.org.pa,
         Milton Mueller <mueller at syracuse.edu>, raul at inia.org.uy,
         adcom at icann-ncc.org
References: 1 , 2

YJ Park wrote:
> 

I Vote for Erick Iriarte.
Thnk you for your kind attention.
Pablo Allietti

> Pabloa,
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Discuss mailing list
> Discuss at icann-ncc.org
> http://www.icann-ncc.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss
========================================================================================

I do not want to participate to this system. The constituency is going
nowhere with such a lack of formalism and rules, except to be completely
disfranchised within the DNSO and the ICANN.
Once more, the adcom has proved to be unable to manage the constituency.
As adcom member, I tried to keep the vote on the right track at the
begining, to fix a first failure of the voting officers before the
start. As candidate, I was not in a position to do anything else, except
observing what was going on. Too much for me!

I have no trust anymore in this vote process and I am not going to
support it by participating to the second round, and I will not
participate to this non-trusted adcom (not because of candidates, but
because the election process).

I let Erik Iriarte to appreciate the situation for himself.

Dany

-- 
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Dany VANDROMME                    |  Directeur du GIP RENATER

                Reseau National de Telecommunications
         pour la Technologie, l'Enseignement et la Recherche

                                  |  ENSAM
Tel   :  +33 (0)1 53 94 20 30     |  151 Boulevard de l'Hopital
Fax   :  +33 (0)1 53 94 20 31     |  75013 Paris
E-mail: Dany.Vandromme at renater.fr |  FRANCE
--------------------------------------------------------------------