[ncdnhc-discuss] Board Positions on .ORG

[Milton Mueller]

>>> "Alejandro Pisanty - DGSCA y FQ, UNAM" <apisan at servidor.unam.mx>
04/01/02 05:39PM >>>

> much of this ground was covered in the Board discussion in Accra
about
> .org, when we stated that judging/policing non-commercial use would 
> be difficult and muddy, and would require an opinon about content.
> It's good to see the discussion played out in more detail.

This is an odd comment. The same discussion 
was "played out in detail" on the NCDNHC list last summer, 
played out in more detail among the NC Task Force. And
yet, Alejandro, you voted against a NCDNHC resolution stating that
same point. How interesting.

Many have always suspected the ICANN management/Board
to suffer from a "Not Invented Here" syndrome.
Here is evidence. If the Board has a discussion and comes to
a conclusion it's a great idea. If the idea comes from the bottom 
up, it's greeted with suspicion, or it doesn't even exist.