[ncdnhc-discuss] Resolution on ORG Divestiture

[Dave Crocker]

At 08:27 AM 10/25/2001, Milton Mueller wrote:
>Vany:
>The link you show below shows that the
>constituency discussions clearly "oppose
>any evictions" and "urge that .org remain
>an unrestricted domain."

Milton, the link points to a note that you sent, claiming an emerging 
consensus.  It does not declare a consensus and it does not substantiate 
any claims.

The difference between your making a claim and your offering -- or 
indicating the existence of -- proof of a claim is rather important, don't 
you think?


>In addition to that process on the list
>back in June, I engaged in direct consultations
>with a broad spectrum of North American
>groups in late July and early August.

Ahh.  So now we have Milton to claiming to have access to the ultimate 
truth, no matter whether discussions on this list agree with the positions 
he espouses or not.

Milton, the work of discussion and consensus building is supposed to happen 
here.  On this list.  You have not been delegated to formulate some sort of 
global position and then espouse it on behalf of this group.


>In fact, during the Names Council ORG
>Task Force process, members of two
>other constituencies praised the consultation
>work we did,

perhaps you could provide a point to the exchange in which you reported 
that consultation process and were praised for it.  it would be most 
enlightening to find out what claims you made.

d/

----------
Dave Crocker  <mailto:dcrocker at brandenburg.com>
Brandenburg InternetWorking  <http://www.brandenburg.com>
tel +1.408.246.8253;  fax +1.408.273.6464