[NCUC-DISCUSS] NCUC Delegate to the ICANN 2016 NominatingCommittee

[Arun Mohan Sukumar]

My two cents -- speaking personally, as I've moved from the national law
university delhi and do not represent the organisation here..

1. In principle, I strongly endorse Remmy's call for greater geographical
diversity in NCUC nominating/appointed positions. Diversity by region
should, however, not be an article of faith. The candidate's background
must be weighed against her activity and participation in NCUC. Offering
candidates from under-represented regions who rarely correspond or attend
ICANN meetings does more disservice to the constituency that serve any real
cause.

2. Diversity in regional representation is not necessarily correlated to
diversity in perspective. If an NCUC representative from a developing
region is beholden to the same set of entrenched, institutional interests,
say as the ICANN Board and reluctant to challenge status quo, that would be
worrisome. Personally, I would rather vote for or support individuals from
developed countries offering sound criticism of ICANN policies. For e.g.,
IP Justice appears to be run by individuals from US and Europe, but I
cannot appreciate enough their flagging of IPR concerns which matter
enormously to countries, like India.

3. Diversity requirements should not be met by appointments/nominations
alone but by populating the general ranks of the Constituency. The NCUC, in
my limited interactions with the group, is far too inward looking and
occupied with ICANN election politics or its (tough) battles with other
SO/AC groups. It does not perform a satisfactory job of co-opting greater
numbers from the developing world, and this responsibility lies squarely
with NCUC leaders from this region. Any NCUC member who seeks an elected
post on the claim of greater diversity ought to highlight her efforts in
recruiting or spreading the word about NCUC from her region. Otherwise, it
becomes a self-fulfilling exercise.

4. Diversity is a key requirement but just as sensitive is the job
eligibility criteria. The ICANN NomCom role is clearly one that requires a
strong network of global contacts, competencies in recruitment, and more
importantly a willingness to engage contrasting perspectives. For these
reasons, I support Bill's candidature to the NomCom.

Arun

On Wed, Aug 5, 2015 at 1:08 PM, David Cake <dave at difference.com.au> wrote:

>
> On 5 Aug 2015, at 1:12 am, Remmy Nweke <remmyn at GMAIL.COM> wrote:
>
> Thanks Stephanie,
> That is the same point I just made too, even if it means rotational
> delegation structure, NCUC could come up with.
>
>
> Our selection procedures are all based on elected groups that incorporate
> regional representational rules (that is, either the EC for NCUC, or the PC
> for NCSG, both of which are elected positions with rules that ensure
> regional diversity).
>
> Frankly speaking in NCUC history, Africa for instance has been
> under-represented alongside others.
>
> A rethink is most welcome.
>
>
> I think Africa has been under-represented in ICANN generally, but NCUC is
> doing better than ICANN generally. But of course that is no reason to be
> complacent.
>
> But I personally think this is the wrong method. Many positions that are
> selected have quite specific requirements for the needed skills (NomCom
> among them). NCUC is not so large that among the active volunteers we will
> always find someone with the appropriate skills and qualities and
> experience, let alone a good candidate from each region. Let us, by all
> means, have regional diversity requirements where appropriate for positions
> where we can select several people (like NCSG council). But for individual
> positions with specific requirements, let regional diversity one of several
> considerations that the selection process can balance while selecting the
> best candidate for NCUCs goals.
>
>  We need stronger capacity building, we need to find ways to bring people
> into the work of NCUC, and regional diversity is certainly a goal. Our goal
> should certainly be to build up NCUC to the point where we have a strong
> pool of regionally diverse candidates for every position that we need to
> fill. But we are not there yet, and for some positions it needs to be
> balanced against the pool of appropriate candidates carefully.
>
> This is not to say that others should not nominate, of course. But lets
> leave the selection to our (elected, regionally diverse) EC and trust them
> to act in the best interests of us all.
>
> David
>
> Remmy Nweke
>
> ____
> REMMY NWEKE,  Lead Strategist/Group Executive Editor,
> DigitalSENSE Africa Media Ltd [*Multiple-award winning medium*]
> (DigitalSENSE Business News
> <http://www.digitalsenseafrica.com.ng/businessnews>; ITREALMS
> <http://www.itrealms.com.ng/>, NaijaAgroNet
> <http://www.naijaagronet.com.ng/>)
> Block F1, Shop 133 Moyosore Aboderin Plaza, Bolade Junction, Oshodi-Lagos
> M: 234-8033592762, 8023122558, 8051000475, T: @ITRealms
> <http://www.twitter.com/ITRealms>
> Author: A Decade of ICT Reportage in Nigeria
> <https://www.facebook.com/adecadeofictreportageinnigeria%E2%80%8E>
> NDSF 2016
> <https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10153112418861429&set=a.119216361428.104226.716351428&type=1>
> _________________________________________________________________
> *Confidentiality Notice:* The information in this document and attachments
> are confidential and may also be privileged information. It is intended
> only for the use of the named recipient. Remmy Nweke does not accept legal
> responsibility for the contents of this e-mail. If you are not the intended
> recipient, please notify me immediately, then delete this document and do
> not disclose the contents of this document to any other person, nor make
> any copies. Violators may face court persecution.
>
> On Tue, Aug 4, 2015 at 5:53 PM, Stephanie Perrin <
> stephanie.perrin at mail.utoronto.ca> wrote:
>
>> While I have already indicated my support for Bill, may I also suggest,
>> as a tired multiple commentator on the Westlake GNSO review, that we need
>> to ensure a lively, diverse field of candidates for all these positions, so
>> that we are not fulfilling the criticism of not enough rotation of senior
>> (travel-funded) positions in our constituency/stakeholder group.   I
>> suspect noone will want to run against Bill, but we do need to have
>> elections, not acclamations.
>>
>> Kind regards,
>> Stephanie
>>
>> On 2015-08-04 12:44, "Kleinwächter, Wolfgang" wrote:
>>
>>> Many thanks to Brenden for a great Job!
>>>
>>> Wolfgang
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> -----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
>>> Von: ncuc-discuss-bounces at lists.ncuc.org im Auftrag von Anriette
>>> Esterhuysen
>>> Gesendet: Di 04.08.2015 16:37
>>> An: ncuc-discuss at lists.ncuc.org
>>> Betreff: Re: [NCUC-DISCUSS] NCUC Delegate to the ICANN 2016
>>> NominatingCommittee
>>>   Dear Bill
>>>
>>> Who has played this role in the past? I recall Adam has, and of course
>>> Brenden. And once Karen Banks from APC did too.. a long time ago :)
>>>
>>> Why don't you take this on? Will you have time?
>>>
>>> Anriette
>>> APC
>>>
>>>
>>> On 04/08/2015 16:08, William Drake wrote:
>>>
>>>>
>>>> Begin forwarded message:
>>>>>
>>>>> *From: *Joette Youkhanna <joette.youkhanna at icann.org
>>>>> <mailto:joette.youkhanna at icann.org>>
>>>>> *Subject: **Non-Commercial Users Constituency Delegate to the ICANN
>>>>> 2016 Nominating Committee*
>>>>> *Date: *August 4, 2015 at 12:37:33 AM GMT+2
>>>>> *To: *William Drake <william.drake at uzh.ch <mailto:william.drake at uzh.ch
>>>>> >>
>>>>> *Cc: *"Stephane Van Gelder (svg at milathan.com
>>>>> <mailto:svg at milathan.com>)" <svg at milathan.com
>>>>> <mailto:svg at milathan.com>>, "Ron Andruff (RA at ONRconsulting.com
>>>>> <mailto:RA at ONRconsulting.com>)" <RA at ONRconsulting.com
>>>>> <mailto:RA at ONRconsulting.com>>, Cheryl Langdon-Orr
>>>>> <langdonorr at gmail.com <mailto:langdonorr at gmail.com>>, Marika Konings
>>>>> <marika.konings at icann.org <mailto:marika.konings at icann.org>>, "Jia-Juh
>>>>> Kimoto" <jiajuh.kimoto at icann.org <mailto:jiajuh.kimoto at icann.org>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Dear Bill,
>>>>>   This email is sent on behalf of the 2016 Nominating Committee
>>>>> (NomCom)
>>>>> Chair, still to be appointed by the ICANN Board of Directors and ask
>>>>> that the stakeholder groups and constituencies of the Generic Names
>>>>> Supporting Organization (GNSO) select a delegates to join the 2016
>>>>> NomCom. Brenden Kuerbis (NCUC delegate) served on the 2014 and 2015
>>>>> NomComs and is not eligible to serve another term.
>>>>>   The composition of the NomCom is outlined in Article VII, Section 2.
>>>>> Composition of ICANN's Bylaws:
>>>>> (http://www.icann.org/en/about/governance/bylaws#VII)
>>>>>   */"Section 2. COMPOSITION/*
>>>>> /The Nominating Committee shall be composed of the following persons:/
>>>>> /1. A non-voting Chair, appointed by the ICANN Board;/
>>>>> /2. A non-voting Chair-Elect, appointed by the ICANN Board as a
>>>>> non-voting advisor;/
>>>>> /3. A non-voting liaison appointed by the ICANN Root Server System
>>>>> Advisory Committee established by Article XI of these Bylaws
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#XI-2.3>;/
>>>>> /4. A non-voting liaison appointed by the ICANN Security and Stability
>>>>> Advisory Committee established by Article XI of these Bylaws
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#XI-2.2>;/
>>>>> /5. A non-voting liaison appointed by the Governmental Advisory
>>>>> Committee
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#XI-2.1>;/
>>>>> /6. Subject to the provisions of the Transition Article of these
>>>>> Bylaws, five voting delegates selected by the At-Large Advisory
>>>>> Committee established by Article XI of these Bylaws
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#XI-2.4>;/
>>>>> /7. Voting delegates to the Nominating Committee shall be selected
>>>>> from the Generic Names Supporting Organization, established by Article
>>>>> X of these Bylaws
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#X-5.3>, as
>>>>> follows:/
>>>>> /a. One delegate from the Registries Stakeholder Group;/
>>>>> /b. One delegate from the Registrars Stakeholder Group;/
>>>>> /c. Two delegates from the Business Constituency, one representing
>>>>> small business users and one representing large business users;/
>>>>> /d. One delegate from the Internet Service Providers Constituency;/
>>>>> /e. One delegate from the Intellectual Property Constituency; and/
>>>>> /f. One delegate from consumer and civil society groups, selected by
>>>>> the Non-Commercial Users Constituency./
>>>>> /8. One voting delegate each selected by the following entities:/
>>>>> /a. The Council of the Country Code Names Supporting Organization
>>>>> established by Article IX of these Bylaws
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#IX>;/
>>>>> /b. The Council of the Address Supporting Organization established
>>>>> by Article VIII of these Bylaws
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#VIII>;
>>>>> and/
>>>>> /c. The Internet Engineering Task Force./
>>>>> /9. A non-voting Associate Chair, who may be appointed by the Chair,
>>>>> at his or her sole discretion, to serve during all or part of the term
>>>>> of the Chair. The Associate Chair may not be a person who is otherwise
>>>>> a member of the same Nominating Committee. The Associate Chair shall
>>>>> assist the Chair in carrying out the duties of the Chair, but shall
>>>>> not serve, temporarily or otherwise, in the place of the Chair."/
>>>>>   We would be grateful if you could make your selection as soon as
>>>>> possible, but no later than *Friday, 21 August 2015*.
>>>>>   We hope service on the NomCom will be interesting and rewarding.  The
>>>>> 2016 NomCom will select 3 Directors of the ICANN Board, 2 members of
>>>>> the ALAC, 1 member of the GNSO Council, and 1 member of the ccNSO
>>>>> Council.
>>>>>   All 2016 NomCom members should be able to attend the first formal
>>>>> meeting of the 2016 NomCom in Dublin, Ireland which is anticipated to
>>>>> be held at the conclusion of the ICANN 54 meeting, 18 - 22
>>>>> October 2015. Travel and hotel accommodation will be provided.
>>>>>   Please note the following as you select and appoint your delegate to
>>>>> the 2016 NomCom:
>>>>>
>>>>>    * Specific criteria for selecting a delegate to the NomCom is
>>>>>      provided in Article VII, Section 4 of ICANN's Bylaws
>>>>>      (http://www.icann.org/en/about/governance/bylaws#VII)
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>     *"Section 4. CRITERIA FOR SELECTION OF NOMINATING COMMITTEE
>>>>> DELEGATES*
>>>>> /Delegates to the ICANN Nominating Committee shall be:/
>>>>> /1. Accomplished persons of integrity, objectivity, and intelligence,
>>>>> with reputations for sound judgment and open minds, and with
>>>>> experience and competence with collegial large group decision-making;/
>>>>> /2. Persons with wide contacts, broad experience in the Internet
>>>>> community, and a commitment to the success of ICANN;/
>>>>> /3. Persons whom the selecting body is confident will consult widely
>>>>> and accept input in carrying out their responsibilities;/
>>>>> /4. Persons who are neutral and objective, without any fixed personal
>>>>> commitments to particular individuals, organizations, or commercial
>>>>> objectives in carrying out their Nominating Committee
>>>>> responsibilities;/
>>>>> /5. Persons with an understanding of ICANN's mission and the potential
>>>>> impact of ICANN's activities on the broader Internet community who are
>>>>> willing to serve as volunteers, without compensation other than the
>>>>> reimbursement of certain expenses; and/
>>>>> /6. Persons who are able to work and communicate in written and spoken
>>>>> English."/
>>>>>
>>>>>    * NomCom delegates should have a high level network of contacts
>>>>>      essential to candidate recruitment (and we hope the NCUC) - as
>>>>>      sending entity will support your delegate and help them with
>>>>>      outreach).
>>>>>
>>>>>    * Eligibility Exception - No person who is an employee of or paid
>>>>>      consultant to ICANN (including the Ombudsman) shall simultaneously
>>>>>      serve in any of the Nominating Committee positions as described in
>>>>>      Article VII, Section 2 of ICANN's Bylaws
>>>>>      (https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/bylaws-2012-02-25-en#VII-2
>>>>> ).
>>>>>
>>>>>    * The person should be able to join monthly teleconferences
>>>>>      (typically 13:00 or 14:00 UTC).  Note that the committee's
>>>>>      workload _will increase_ significantly during Apr/May/June 2016
>>>>>      when the candidate assessment process will be at its busiest.
>>>>>      Conference calls are held more frequently (typically weekly)
>>>>>      during this time as well.
>>>>>
>>>>>    * The person must be able to attend the NomCom selection meeting in
>>>>>      late June 2016.
>>>>>
>>>>>    * The person should be willing to work in a large,
>>>>>      consensus-oriented committee.
>>>>>
>>>>>   The NomCom have _guideline
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/2015-guidelines-2014-11-14-en>_
>>>>> and _procedure
>>>>> <https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/2015-procedures-2014-11-14-en>_
>>>>> documents
>>>>> for reference that provide additional information about the work of
>>>>> the NomCom.
>>>>>   Please consider geographic diversity of the NomCom when making your
>>>>> selection of delegate.
>>>>>   We would appreciate your acknowledging receipt of this message, and
>>>>> please send the name of the NCUC delegate no later than Friday, 21
>>>>> August 2015 to NomCom Staff Support, Joette Youkhanna
>>>>> at: joette.youkhanna at icann.org <mailto:joette.youkhanna at icann.org> and
>>>>> Jia Kimoto at: jia-juh.kimoto at icann.org <mailto:
>>>>> jia-juh.kimoto at icann.org>.
>>>>>   Many thanks in advance for helping the 2016 NomCom get off to a good
>>>>> start!
>>>>>     Warm regards,
>>>>>   Stephane Van Gelder, Chair - 2015 NomCom
>>>>> Ron Andruff, Chair Elect - 2015 NomCom
>>>>> Cheryl Langdon-Orr, Associate Chair - 2015 NomCom
>>>>>     -------
>>>>>   Joette Youkhanna
>>>>> Jia Kimoto
>>>>> NomCom Staff
>>>>>   Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers
>>>>> 12025 Waterfront Drive, Suite 300
>>>>> Los Angeles, CA USA 90094-2536
>>>>>
>>>> *********************************************************
>>>> William J. Drake
>>>> International Fellow & Lecturer
>>>>    Media Change & Innovation Division, IPMZ
>>>>    University of Zurich, Switzerland
>>>> Chair, Noncommercial Users Constituency,
>>>>    ICANN, www.ncuc.org <http://www.ncuc.org>
>>>> william.drake at uzh.ch
>>>> <mailto:william.drake at uzh.ch> (direct), wjdrake at gmail.com
>>>> <mailto:wjdrake at gmail.com> (lists),
>>>>    www.williamdrake.org <http://www.williamdrake.org>
>>>> /Internet Governance: The NETmundial Roadmap /http://goo.gl/sRR01q
>>>> *********************************************************
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Ncuc-discuss mailing list
>>>> Ncuc-discuss at lists.ncuc.org
>>>> http://lists.ncuc.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/ncuc-discuss
>>>>
>>>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Ncuc-discuss mailing list
>>
>> Ncuc-discuss at lists.ncuc.org
>> http://lists.ncuc.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/ncuc-discuss
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Ncuc-discuss mailing list
> Ncuc-discuss at lists.ncuc.org
> http://lists.ncuc.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/ncuc-discuss
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Ncuc-discuss mailing list
> Ncuc-discuss at lists.ncuc.org
> http://lists.ncuc.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/ncuc-discuss
>
>


-- 
Head, Cyber Initiative
Observer Research Foundation, New Delhi
http://amsukumar.tumblr.com
+91-9871943272
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ncuc.org/pipermail/ncuc-discuss/attachments/20150805/3c15c6c4/attachment-0002.html>