Comment on WHOIS Policy Review Team Draft Report

[Maria Farrell]

Hi Avri,

Quick request for clarification re,:

"The draft document frequently speaks of the authority of national law in
requiring Registrars and Thick Registries to turn over privacy and proxy
data. However, when that national law is in contravention to international
law on human rights, it MUST not be honored."

What is the 'it' that must be honored. Grammatically, I think it's national
law, but substantively it would be international law..?

Many thanks, m

On 18 March 2012 18:43, Alain Berranger <alain.berranger at gmail.com> wrote:

> Avri,
>
> ...your recommendation seems absolutely necessary and you have argued it
> superbly... it may prove critical in future cases brought in front of the
> International Court of Justice or other courts of justice...
>
> Alain
>
>
> On Sun, Mar 18, 2012 at 1:54 PM, Avri Doria <avri at acm.org> wrote:
>
>> Comment on draft-final-report-05dec11-en.pdf
>>
>> While I support the comments submitted by the NCSG <
>> http://forum.icann.org/lists/whois-rt-draft-final-report/msg00021.html>,
>> I wish to discuss further a point that were merely alluded to in that
>> comment.  My comment relate to cross jurisdictional limits on national
>> sovereignty in relation to human rights.
>>
>> Just as the ICANN community often speaks of "bad actors" among Registrars
>> and Registrants, we must recognize that 'bad actors' exist among the
>> governments of the world.  By 'bad actors' among the governments of the
>> world, I refer to those governments who consistently violate the principles
>> of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) <
>> http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/> and the International Covenant on
>> Civil and Political Rights  (ICCPR) <
>> http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/ccpr.htm>, as well as other
>> international treaties and covenants.   As with 'bad actors' within the
>> Regstrars and Registrants, the 'bad actors' within governments are a
>> minority, but they do exist.  I refer specifically, not only to those
>> governments who use private data to prosecute citizens for freedom of
>> speech and association, but those who persecute and imprison, and sometimes
>> worse, their citizens for the 'crime' of being gay, i.e for having a gender
>> orientation or gender expression that is outside their narrow cultural
>> norms.
>>
>> The draft document frequently speaks of the authority of national law in
>> requiring Registrars and Thick Registries to turn over privacy and proxy
>> data. However, when that national law is in contravention to international
>> law on human rights, it MUST not be honored.  It is bad enough that these
>> governmental 'bad actors' could force the Registrars and the Thick
>> Registries within their own borders to comply with their illegal demands,
>> it is unacceptable that ICANN should become complicit in their crimes
>> against humanity by virtue of its contractual rules on Registrars and Thick
>> Registries.
>>
>> As United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki Moon said on 29 January 2012
>> in an address to the leaders of the African Union
>>
>> "
>> Let me mention one form of discrimination that has been ignored or even
>> sanctioned by many states for far too long, discrimination based on sexual
>> orientation or gender identity.  This has prompted some governments to
>> treat people as second-class citizens, or even criminals. Confronting this
>> discrimination is a challenge.  But we must live up to the ideals of the
>> Universal Declaration [of Human Rights]
>> "
>>
>> This is similar to remarks made by United States Secretary of State
>> Hillary Clinton Hillary Clinton in her Human Rights Day speech, delivered
>> in Geneva on 6 December 2011.
>>
>> "
>> Like being a woman, like being a racial, religious, tribal, or ethnic
>> minority, being LGBT does not make you less human. And that is why gay
>> rights are human rights, and human rights are gay rights.
>>
>> It is violation of human rights when people are beaten or killed because
>> of their sexual orientation, or because they do not conform to cultural
>> norms about how men and women should look or behave. It is a violation of
>> human rights when governments declare it illegal to be gay, or allow those
>> who harm gay people to go unpunished. It is a violation of human rights
>> when lesbian or transgendered women are subjected to so-called corrective
>> rape, or forcibly subjected to hormone treatments, or when people are
>> murdered after public calls for violence toward gays, or when they are
>> forced to flee their nations and seek asylum in other lands to save their
>> lives. And it is a violation of human rights when life-saving care is
>> withheld from people because they are gay, or equal access to justice is
>> denied to people because they are gay, or public spaces are out of bounds
>> to people because they are gay. No matter what we look like, where we come
>> from, or who we are, we are all equally entitled to our human rights and
>> dignity.
>> "
>>
>> Likewise it is a violation of human rights for ICANN rules on REVEAL to
>> endanger populations and associations whose only crime is in expressing
>> their human rights and thus to expose them to the crimes against humanity
>> committed by their governments under the pretext of it being illegal to be
>> gay.
>>
>> My recommendation for the final report is that whenever, the authority of
>> national law is referred to in the WHOIS Review recommendations, it should
>> include the qualifier "contingent on adherence to Internationally
>> recognized covenants and treaties on Human Rights",  so that the authority
>> of governmental 'bad actors' is blocked from extending contractually to
>> Registrars and Registries.
>>
>> Thank you
>>
>> Avri Doria
>>
>
>
>
> --
> Alain Berranger, B.Eng, MBA
> Member, Board of Directors, CECI, http://www.ceci.ca<http://www.ceci.ca/en/about-ceci/team/board-of-directors/>
> Executive-in-residence, Schulich School of Business, www.schulich.yorku.ca
> Trustee, Global Knowledge Partnership Foundation, www.gkpfoundation.org
> NA representative, Chasquinet Foundation, www.chasquinet.org
> interim Membership Committee Chair, NPOC, NCSG, ICANN, http://npoc.org/
> O:+1 514 484 7824; M:+1 514 704 7824
> Skype: alain.berranger
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ncuc.org/pipermail/ncuc-discuss/attachments/20120318/ee82d15b/attachment-0001.html>