17.12.08 GNSO WHOIS Discussion

[Norbert Klein]

On Thursday, 18 December 2008 00:24:19 William Drake wrote:
> Hello,
>
> Is anyone else planning on being on the WHOIS call that commences in
> less than an hour, 18:00 UTC?
>

Hi Bill,

I am sorry to be so late - back from travel and still overwhelmed with work
backlog.

I am sure you got this mail:

From: "Tim Ruiz" <tim at godaddy.com>
  To: "Council GNSO" <council at gnso.icann.org>
  Date: 16.12.2008 23:43

At the end he says:

"Comment of RrC: The RrC continues to maintain that no studies should be
pursued. We have over six years of history 							
on this topic. It was clear through those years that the stakeholder groups
were entrenched in their views and positions									
and there is no evidence or any other indication that any of these studies
will change that."

It was probably six years ago, that we were already informed that
now "everything is clear for WHOIS except one point where there is a
controversy: the purpose of the WHOIS data."

This situation is in Tim's comment also: we have discussed things to the end,
we once voted - majority, not only NCUC - that the WHOIS process has looked
into all aspects and now we decide - and after the GNSO Council had decided,
the process was rolled up again.

In the NCUC, we have basically maintained through all these years that the
WHOIS data have been created with a clear purpose: to identify the
person/institution who is the holder of a domain - for technical contact and
billing etc. That was our general position over the years.

All additions are "alien" to this - there are procedures for law enforcement
and Intellectual Property concerns - technical and legal - and in he NCUC we
used to say that ICANN (as also ICANN's statute says) is for the stability of
the network. So no burdening with alien tasks - for which there are state
laws and regulations.

I think to go along with the statement by Tim Ruiz is historically and
contentwise the NCUC majority position.


Norbert								


--
Phnom Penh/Cambodia
PGP key-id 0x0016D0A9

If you want to know what is going on in Cambodia, please visit us regularly -
you can find something new every day:

http://cambodiamirror.wordpress.com (English)
http://kanhchoksangkum.wordpress.com (Khmer)