Response from Rita Rodin

[Norbert Klein]

This is the response from Rita Rodin, the other candidate for the ICANN 
board. She also agree that I share her response with the NCUConstituency.

Norbert

=

Hi Norbert –

Thanks for your mail. It is very inspiring to hear the stories of those 
like yourself who strive to make a difference and better the lives of 
others.

I was listening to the news this evening, and heard that the EU has 
stopped funding the Hamas-lead Palestinian government because it refuses 
to renounce violence. The report stated that this has lead to, among 
other things, hospitals running out of supplies and people therefore 
having to sell their valuables and other personal items to procure 
medicine for their sick.

I have traveled a bit around the world, and in my experience, people 
around the world are similar in many ways but particularly in one 
fundamental way - - they want to provide for their families and educate 
their children.

What is so unjust to me about scenarios like that described above is 
that it is not the government that truly suffers from bad policy, but 
the people of that government, who may be powerless to effect change. 
The same people who are simply trying to live a life that they should be 
entitled to live.

The Internet has undeniably been and continues to be an amazing 
phenomenon and catalyst for change. However, there is still a long and 
arduous road ahead to enable people around the world to harness its 
power and potential.

The creation of the NCUC was in my view a huge step towards trying to 
provide the user, wherever she may be, with a voice towards achieving 
that end. I think that the challenge for ICANN now is to make some 
progress on that front, and I believe that the organization needs to 
continue to receive the views of people like yourself who are involved 
in less advanced areas of the world, so that it can understand and 
address the nuances of the needs of these areas.

Open source may be one solution. In my experience, open source software 
is becoming much more "mainstream" and, perhaps with the new version of 
the GPL, more companies will readily utilize, promote and develop open 
source applications. I think that if the community believes that ICANN 
should be a forum to facilitate discussions about using open source to 
help bridge the gap, that it should certainly be given serious 
consideration by the Board. I am not quite sure why people objected to 
your use of open source in such a visceral way. It certainly seems like 
a reasonable approach which at a minimum, should be looked at more closely.

I hope that this was helpful. Please let me know if you or any of your 
constituency members have any other questions or concerns. I hope to be 
able to meet you in Marrakech. I was planning on going even before 
deciding to run for the Board, so I will be there either way, and hope 
to see you there.

Thank you very much for your consideration.

Warm regards,

Rita

=

Hi Rita,

sorry, my mail is 24 hours later than I had planned for.

Thanks for your mail -- I had also read some time ago your statement 
before the first round of the election, and I had intended to write at 
that time, because you made a reference to Open Source software.

May I first introduce myself a little bit more. I started the first 
connection to the Internet from Cambodia in 1994 -- from a dial-up 
system I created on a notebook, US$ 5.- per minute on a slow slow slow 
connection to San Francisco, and for three years I was the only provider 
in Cambodia, having about 1500 users by the time the first two big 
commercial ISPs were set up. - I am employed by a Cambodian NGO -- the 
Open Forum of Cambodia -- committed to facilitate and to foster 
communication in Cambodian society, not only by electronic means, though 
these were important to help break the decades of international 
isolation of the country -- self imposed or enforced from the outside, 
as times changed.

Having done some "pioneering" things in Cambodia, I was invited to join 
the non-commercial constituency of ICANN since 1999, and whenever I 
could find sponsorship I participated -- later as an elected member of 
the Executive Committee of the Non Commercial Users Constituency -- NCUC

- and from there sent into the GNSO Council.

Considering your candidacy for the ICANN Board, I do not want to ask 
some of the standard policy questions, but I would rather like to ask to 
kindly send some comments back about an experience I had recently. If 
you find the time to respond, however briefly or more in detail, I would 
like to ask for your understanding that I would like to share your 
response with the NCUC constituency. My experience relates to one 
concern of the NCUC -- how to maintain and possibly extend the field for 
open and unhindered communication. Many people living in more advanced 
economies think that communication is often in danger of being 
controlled politically (which can also happen); here it is restricted by 
our economic environment -- a high-school teacher gets about US$ 35 a 
month (thirty five -- I did not forget a zero).

=

I did participate in the two UN Summits for the Information Society, and 
also in some of the preparatory meetings for both. Probably you know 
that they had been set up, by a resolution of the UN General Assembly, 
as "multi-stakeholder" processes: for governments, inter-governmental 
agencies, business, and civil society.

During the last preparatory conference for WSIS 2 in Tunis, in Geneva 
October 2005, there were many smaller working groups feeding into the 
plenaries, and one was on Cultural Identity, chaired by an ambassador 
from Egypt. After all the nice things were said which Geneva WSIS 2003 
had beautifully formulated in the first paragraph of the Declaration of 
Principles, comments were invited about "success stories" - how this 
really works.

I offered to speak, the chair recognized me, I identified myself with my 
background in an NGO, and then I shared what we are doing -- after 
waiting in vain for years that the promises of a certain well known 
software company to make their OS and their main applications available 
in the Khmer language and script would come true. (I had been involved 
in finalizing the UNICODE standard for the Khmer script in mid 2002 -- 
and since January 2003 we had to readjust our expectations to July, and 
then to next year, and so on -- until today: nothing.)

So I shared that our organization had started to develop free Open 
Source software in the Cambodian language, based on the UNICODE standard

-- we have now a browser, a mailer, the whole Open Office 2.0 suite, and 
a number of utilities. As the name says: Open Source software allows 
access to the source, and therefore the process of "localization" - to 
change the user interface into another language, and to allow the system 
to handle a different script - is possible and legal. The National 
Information Technology Authority of the Cambodian government picked up 
our drive and is promoting it, the Ministry of Education got involved, 
and what we do is opening up the possibility for thousands of people who 
do not speak a foreign language to learn how to use a computer -- and to 
use it at the place of work -- in their own language, and without having 
to pay one full year's salary for the equipment of a computer with legal 
software according to the standard prices.

While I spoke, a person in the room went up to the chair, I was asked to 
identify myself again. On the strong insistence of the intervener (I 
could not identify her institutionally, but I was told that this person 
was from the official US delegation), I was requested to leave the room

- and I was told that my inference that Open Source software is more 
suited than commercial software for localization is wrong, 
discriminatory, and not acceptable.

So much for the "level playing field" in overcoming the digital divide.

The gap is at present actually not so big, as almost all software, 
whatever is on a disk, is freely available on CDs for US$2 a piece -- 
but since Cambodia became a member of the WTO, there is a growing threat 
that "piracy" will not be tolerated in future. But if this should 
happen, probably computerization in the field of education will come to 
a grinding halt for economic reasons (unless Open Source software is 
made the regular choice in procurement).

Pirates -- as we know them from the movies -- are prepared to kill to 
achieve their goals. We know about piracy not only from the movies, but 
it happens also occasionally that a small cargo ship from Singapore does 
no longer carry what they loaded before entering the Mekong River in 
Vietnam and come upstream to Cambodia. I cannot explain to Cambodian 
friends why it is compared to a crime of brutal violence, when knowledge 
is shared.

I know all - well, surely not all - the legal answers given by the IP 
and business representatives. I live and work with other people who do 
neither know much about these legalities, and who have difficulty to 
follow, when one explains. But they are more and more part of the same 
global information society, for which the WSIS meetings were held, and 
for which ICANN tries to provide a service in a limited field.

I would appreciate some comments back which go beyond a narrowly defined 
ICANN mandate.

Thanks for your attention -- if you read through my somewhat lengthy letter.

And see you in Marrakesh?

Norbert

****************************************************
This e-mail and any attachments thereto, is intended only for use by the 
addressee(s) named herein and may contain legally privileged and/or 
confidential information. If you are not the intended recipient of this 
e-mail, you are hereby notified any dissemination, distribution or 
copying of this email, and any attachments thereto, is strictly 
prohibited. If you receive this email in error please immediately notify 
me at (212) 735-3000 and permanently delete the original copy and any 
copy of any e-mail, and any printout thereof.

Further information about the firm, a list of the Partners and their 
professional qualifications will be provided upon request.
****************************************************