[ncdnhc-discuss] Vany's ORG resolution

[Nilda Vany Martinez Grajales]

Milton:

Milton Mueller wrote:

> Vany:
>
> I don't support your resolution.
> To make things clearer, let me
> list all of the documents involved.
>
> 1. The original, June 2001 "First Views" document
> 2. The Names Council Task Force Report of October 2001
> 3. The Mueller resolution on .ORG proposed for discussion
>      at the Annual Meeting in Marina del Rey
> 4. The Martinez resolution on .ORG proposed for discussion
>      at the Annual Meeting in Marina del Rey
>
> Your resolution asks us to
> a) vote on #1 paragraph by paragraph
> b) apply the results of that vote to #2, and rewrite the NC policy

I am not asking to rewrite the NC policy if the NC votes that they don't
want to write it.
What I am saying is that the NCDNHC finally have an official position on
it based
on its own process of developing such official positions.   And then
such oficial position
made by us internally, then we expose it to Names Council, to
ICANN Board, etc.


> c) Your resolution also proposes a number of permanent
> procedural changes, most of which would be difficult
> to implement and are vaguely defined.

Ok, that will be outlined  more clearly in a separate resolution
proposal.


> By way of contrast, the resolution on .org I
> submitted (#3) simply endorses the Names Council
> Task Force report and certain policies regarding
> org. It is much simpler to handle the .org issue in the
> way I suggest.

Why we have simply to endorse or not endorse something made
by people outside the NCDNHC when we can produce oficial documents and
positions on our own
then to share them to the NC and ICANN Board?


> It would be even simpler, however,
> to just vote on the Names Council TF report itself!

Yes, but there are other issues that are not covered in the  .ORG TF
works that also deserves to be voted (especially those points
2 and 6 of the Initial Position that it seems you want to leave them in
the unknow dimension)

> If the constituency agrees to do that, I will agree
> to withdraw my resolution and Vany can withdraw
> hers. It is rather funny to have resolutions about
> resolutions about policy issues

We don't have any oficial resolution yet about any .ORG policy Milton

Best Regards

Vany

--
Nilda Vany Martinez Grajales
Information Technology Specialist
Sustainable Development Networking Programme/Panama
e-mail: vany at sdnp.org.pa
http://www.sdnp.org.pa